The Uncomfortable Questions · An AI FAQ for leaders

Question #3 · Judgment

What happens to a leader’s judgment after two years of never being the first one with the answer?

The short answer

Borrowed Certainty: confidence that comes from the tool, not from the thinking.

I call it Borrowed Certainty. It feels like strength until the day the tool is wrong or silent. The best leaders I advise form a view first, then check it against the AI. The order matters more than the tool.

Norm E. Murray

The psychology

Why it happens

Borrowed Certainty builds slowly, and it looks exactly like real judgment until the day it’s tested.

01

The first answer anchors you

Psychologists call this anchoring: the first idea we see pulls every later judgment toward it. When the AI always speaks first, its answer becomes the anchor.

02

Confidence gets outsourced

A fluent, well-written answer feels certain. Leaders absorb that certainty and carry it into the room, without the reasoning that would let them defend it.

03

The thinking muscle goes unused

Forming a view from scratch is effortful. Skip it for two years and the skill fades, the same way any unpracticed skill does.

04

The weakness stays hidden

Borrowed Certainty looks like real judgment on a normal day. It only shows when the tool is wrong, unavailable, or facing something it has never seen.

The bottom line: Think first, then prompt. The order matters more than the tool.

Your move

What to do about it

  1. Think first, then prompt.Before you ask the AI, spend five minutes writing your own answer.
  2. Compare, don’t copy.Where the AI’s answer differs from yours, find out why before choosing.
  3. Run meetings the same way.Ask people for their view before anyone shares what the AI said.
  4. Practice without the tool.Make some decisions each month without AI, so the skill stays sharp.
  5. Ask “how do you know?”When someone presents a confident answer, ask for the reasoning, not the source.

From the conversation

What executives said

A chief marketing officer at a cybersecurity advisory firm said she used to ask AI for the answer before her coffee was even warm. Now she sits with her own answer first, so her intuition gets the first word.Paraphrased from a LinkedIn reply