The Uncomfortable Questions · An AI FAQ for leaders
Question #13 · TalentWhen AI does the junior analyst’s work, where do your future senior leaders learn judgment?
The short answer
Junior work was never just output. It was apprenticeship.
The grind of building the model, drafting the memo and getting it torn apart is how judgment forms. Automate it without replacing the learning, and in ten years you’ll have senior titles with no seasoning behind them. I call this the Missing Rung problem.
Norm E. Murray
The psychology
Why it happens
Nobody decides to stop developing future leaders. It happens as a side effect of a sensible efficiency decision.
Judgment is built by doing
Psychologists call it deliberate practice: skill grows through effortful work with fast, honest feedback. Reviewing a machine’s draft is not the same exercise as building the thing yourself and having it torn apart.
Producing beats reading
Researchers call it the generation effect: people understand and remember what they produce far better than what they only read. A junior who edits an AI memo is reading. A junior who writes one is learning.
The irony of automation
Engineers have long described the paradox: the more a system automates, the more the remaining human role depends on skills the system no longer lets people practice. The rare, hard calls land on people who never got the reps.
Everyone assumes someone else will train them
Economists call it the free-rider problem. If every firm cuts junior roles and plans to hire seasoned talent later, the pool of seasoned talent quietly dries up for all of them.
Your move
What to do about it
- Map where judgment used to form.List the junior tasks AI now handles and, for each one, what a junior used to learn by doing it. That list is your training gap.
- Make juniors go first.Have them build the first draft or analysis before they see the AI’s version, then compare the two. The order matters more than the tool.
- Keep the tear-down.Senior people still review junior work closely and explain why. The critique is the curriculum.
- Spend the freed-up time on real decisions.Use the hours AI saves to put junior people in the rooms where calls are made, with a defined role, earlier than they would have been.
- Measure the pipeline, not just the productivity.Track how many people are ready for the next rung each year, alongside hours saved. If one number rises while the other falls, you are borrowing from your future bench.
Keep going
Related questions
Get a sharp take like this every morning
Norm’s Edge is a free daily briefing for leaders: one AI story, one decision, one minute.
Free. One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime with one click.
Prefer to read first? See Norm’s Edge