The Uncomfortable Questions · An AI FAQ for leaders

Question #26 · Economics

If every competitor has the same AI tools, where does your advantage come from?

The short answer

Buying AI is table stakes. Using it with better judgment is the strategy.

When a capability becomes a commodity, it stops being an advantage. The edge moves to what can’t be bought off the shelf: proprietary data, organizational speed, and leaders who know when to trust the tool and when to override it.

Norm E. Murray

The economics

Why it happens

Anything a competitor can buy from the same vendor, at the same price, by next quarter, cannot be the reason you win.

01

What everyone can buy, nobody owns

The resource-based view of strategy holds that lasting advantage comes from resources that are valuable, rare and hard to copy. An AI license is valuable but neither rare nor hard to copy, so it buys parity, not an edge.

02

Running faster to stay in place

Strategists call it the Red Queen effect: when every rival improves at the same pace, nobody’s relative position changes. AI rollouts that match the market keep you in the race without moving you up in it.

03

The value sits in what surrounds the tool

David Teece’s work on complementary assets shows that the gains from a new technology often go to whoever owns what it needs to work: the data, the processes, the customer relationships. The tool is shared; those are not.

04

Some organizations learn faster than others

Cohen and Levinthal called it absorptive capacity: the ability to recognize, absorb and apply new knowledge. Two firms with identical tools get different results because one of them knows how to turn what it learns into decisions.

The bottom line: The tools are rented by everyone. The judgment to use them well belongs only to you.

Your move

What to do about it

  1. Stop presenting AI adoption as a differentiator.If your strategy deck lists the tools you bought as an advantage, take them off that slide. Your competitors can buy the same list.
  2. Map what only you have.List the data, customer relationships and know-how that a rival could not acquire in a year. That list, not the software, is where your AI investment should be aimed.
  3. Measure speed from insight to action.Track how long it takes your organization to act once the AI surfaces something useful. Most of the advantage is lost in that gap, not in the model.
  4. Build judgment, not just usage.Train leaders on when to trust an output and when to override it. Usage figures tell you who logged in; they don’t tell you who decided well.
  5. Ask the parity question every quarter.For each AI initiative, ask: if a competitor did exactly this tomorrow, would we still be ahead? If not, it is table stakes, so fund it like table stakes.