The Uncomfortable Questions · An AI FAQ for leaders
Question #16 · TalentAre you hiring for what AI can’t do yet, or for what it couldn’t do two years ago?
The short answer
Many job descriptions are a snapshot of a world that no longer exists.
The skills that differentiate now are framing the right problem, judging ambiguous evidence, and leading people through change. If your hiring criteria haven’t changed since 2023, your talent strategy is behind your technology strategy.
Norm E. Murray
The psychology
Why it happens
Technology strategies get rewritten every year. Hiring criteria mostly get copied forward, and nobody is assigned to notice the gap.
The status quo default
Economists call it status quo bias: people favor the existing option because changing it takes effort and carries risk. So last year’s job description gets copied forward, with a line about AI added at the bottom.
Jobs are bundles of tasks
Labor economists describe a job as a bundle of tasks, and technology reshapes the bundle before it removes the job. The title stays the same while the work underneath it moves, so hiring criteria tied to the title fall behind.
We hire in our own image
Psychologists call it similarity bias: interviewers rate people higher when they resemble them. Leaders who rose on the old skills keep selecting for those skills, even after those skills stop being scarce.
We measure what is easy to see
Researchers call it the streetlight effect: we search where the light is, not where the answer is. Years of experience and tool lists are easy to screen for. Framing a problem and judging messy evidence are not, so they get skipped.
Your move
What to do about it
- Audit your top ten job descriptions.Mark every requirement AI now handles well. Whatever remains is what you are actually hiring for, and it is often a shorter list.
- Rewrite the role around judgment.Describe the decisions this person will make and the problems they will frame, not the tasks they will complete.
- Test framing, not recall.Hand candidates an ambiguous brief and incomplete evidence. Watch what they ask first, what they doubt, and how they reach a view.
- Make them use the tools in the interview.Let candidates work with AI, then ask them to find what it got wrong. That shows more than any list of tools on a resume.
- Put hiring criteria on the AI agenda.When your technology strategy changes, review your talent criteria in the same meeting, so the two stop drifting apart.
Keep going
Related questions
Get a sharp take like this every morning
Norm’s Edge is a free daily briefing for leaders: one AI story, one decision, one minute.
Free. One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime with one click.
Prefer to read first? See Norm’s Edge