A High Court judgment reported Nov 2 found a Crown Prosecution Service decision record cited a 2024 authority, “R v J,” three times. The court agreed the case does not exist. A senior prosecutor said it was an error and she meant R v JTB [2009] UKHL 20.
Reported by: Legal Futures, on the High Court finding (Nov 2)
Prosecutors cited a case that never existed. Someone signed it off anyway.
Mistaking a polished, well-formatted draft for a verified one.
- Format trust. Clean formatting signals that someone checked the work.
- Rushed review. Reviewers skim what looks familiar and plausible.
- Diffused checking. Each signer assumes someone else opened the source.
The tell: you sign documents whose citations nobody can show were opened.
When did you last open the source behind a citation you signed?
Before your next board or regulatory filing:
- Name a checkerEvery citation carries a named person who opened the source.
- Verify at sourceCheck each authority, statistic and precedent in the original.
- Record the checkLog who verified each reference, and when, before you sign.
One story a day, and the decision it puts in front of you.
Get Norm's Daily BriefAnalysis and opinion, not investment or legal advice. © 2026 Norm E. Murray. All Rights Reserved.
