UK High Court Notes Prosecutors Again Cited a Case That Does Not Exist

UK prosecutors again cited a case that does not exist, and the lesson is who opened the source.

A High Court judgment reported Nov 2 found a Crown Prosecution Service decision record cited a 2024 authority, “R v J,” three times. The court agreed the case does not exist. A senior prosecutor said it was an error and she meant R v JTB [2009] UKHL 20.

Reported by: Legal Futures, on the High Court finding (Nov 2)

Norm's Take

Prosecutors cited a case that never existed. Someone signed it off anyway.

The leader's blind spot
Fluency Bias

Mistaking a polished, well-formatted draft for a verified one.

  • Format trust. Clean formatting signals that someone checked the work.
  • Rushed review. Reviewers skim what looks familiar and plausible.
  • Diffused checking. Each signer assumes someone else opened the source.

The tell: you sign documents whose citations nobody can show were opened.

The question for Monday

When did you last open the source behind a citation you signed?

Before your next board or regulatory filing:

  1. Name a checkerEvery citation carries a named person who opened the source.
  2. Verify at sourceCheck each authority, statistic and precedent in the original.
  3. Record the checkLog who verified each reference, and when, before you sign.

One story a day, and the decision it puts in front of you.

Get Norm's Daily Brief

Analysis and opinion, not investment or legal advice. © 2026 Norm E. Murray. All Rights Reserved.

Found this useful? Share on LinkedIn →
Norm E. Murray, Senior Advisor on AI to CEOs and Boards
About the author
Norm E. Murray
Senior Advisor on AI to CEOs and Boards · Psychologist · Economist
Norm advises CEOs, boards and senior leaders on the psychology and economics of AI adoption: what AI does to leaders and organizations, not just what it does. He has led global businesses across multiple continents and writes The Norm Report for executives navigating the AI shift.
More about Norm →

Get Norm's Daily Brief

One story a day, and the decision it puts in front of you. Free, in your inbox.

Free. One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime with one click.

If something in this analysis bears on a decision you're facing, don't sit on it.

Latest From Norm's Edge

More Analysis for Leaders

Norm’s Edge is analysis and opinion intended for senior executive and board-level audiences. It does not constitute legal, financial, investment, compliance or regulatory advice. Stories are drawn from third-party reporting that may be unconfirmed. Readers should seek independent professional counsel before making decisions based on any content published here. Norm E. Murray does not accept any liability for actions taken in reliance on this analysis.

© 2026 Norm E. Murray. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, distributed or transmitted in any form without the prior written permission of the author.