The Uncomfortable Questions · An AI FAQ for leaders

Question #15 · Talent

Who in your organization is quietly becoming irrelevant, and do they know it yet?

The short answer

Relevance rarely disappears in a layoff.

It erodes quietly, one skipped meeting and one bypassed decision at a time. The people at most risk are often the ones who were best at the old way of working. Leaders owe them an honest conversation early, while there is still time to adapt.

Norm E. Murray

The psychology

Why it happens

Nobody announces that a role is fading. It happens through hundreds of small, reasonable choices that nobody adds up.

01

The competency trap

Organizational researchers call it the competency trap: the better you are at the current way of working, the more you keep refining it and the less you explore the new one. Mastery of the old method becomes the reason people miss the shift.

02

Expertise is identity

Psychologists describe identity threat: when a skill is part of who you are, a tool that does it feels like a verdict on you. People respond by avoiding the tool, which widens the gap.

03

Nobody delivers the bad news

Researchers call it the mum effect: people reliably avoid passing on unwelcome news. Managers route work around someone instead of telling them, so the person is the last to know.

04

Skills depreciate quietly

Economists call it human capital depreciation: skills lose value as technology changes, gradually and without a line on any report. It stays invisible until a restructuring makes it visible all at once.

The bottom line: Quiet irrelevance is a leadership failure before it is a performance problem. Telling people early is both the kind move and the smart one.

Your move

What to do about it

  1. Watch the routing, not the ratings.Notice whose meetings, approvals and input are being skipped since AI arrived. That pattern shows up long before a performance review does.
  2. Have the conversation early and plainly.Tell people what is changing in their role and what will matter next, while there is still time to act on it.
  3. Separate the person from the old method.Name what their experience still gives the organization: context, relationships, judgment on the exceptions. Then point it at the new work.
  4. Give them a real path.Put them on live work with the new tools, with time and support to learn. A one-off training session is not a path.
  5. Make relevance a leadership metric.Ask every leader who on their team is at risk and what they are doing about it, and review the answer as seriously as you review attrition.