The Uncomfortable Questions · An AI FAQ for leaders

Question #18 · Talent

What’s one skill you’ve worked to keep sharp precisely because AI could do it for you?

The short answer

I write my first draft before asking any tool for help, because that’s where I find out what I think.

Athletes train fundamentals long after they’ve mastered them, for the same reason. What’s yours?

Norm E. Murray

The psychology

Why it happens

Skills you stop practicing fade quietly, and the first ones AI takes over are often the ones that build judgment.

01

Use it or lose it

Researchers who study skill decay find that complex skills fade when they go unpracticed, and the decline is hard to notice from the inside. Hand a skill to a tool and you keep the output while the ability quietly erodes.

02

Writing is thinking

Psychologists call it the generation effect: we remember and understand what we produce ourselves far better than what we only read. A first draft is where the thinking happens; accepting one from a tool skips that step.

03

Experts practice the basics

Anders Ericsson’s research on deliberate practice showed that experts stay expert through focused practice, not repetition alone. That is why athletes still drill fundamentals, and why leaders should keep doing some core work the hard way.

04

The out-of-the-loop problem

Human factors researchers describe the out-of-the-loop problem: people who only supervise automation lose the hands-on skill to take over when it fails. The moment you most need the skill is the moment the tool is wrong or unavailable.

The bottom line: Protect the skills that tell you what you think. Let AI support them, not replace them.

Your move

What to do about it

  1. Name your one skill.Pick the skill closest to your judgment, such as writing, analysis or negotiation, and decide to keep doing it yourself.
  2. Go first, then check.Form your own draft or view before asking a tool, then use AI to test and improve it.
  3. Schedule the practice.Put regular time on the calendar to do that work without assistance, the way an athlete drills fundamentals.
  4. Ask your team the same question.Have each leader name the skill they will keep sharp, and protect time for it.
  5. Watch for the slow fade.If you notice you can no longer do something you used to do well, treat it as a warning, not a convenience.